Wednesday, 22 September 2010

Santos Sack Dorival Júnior

If you're a regular reader, you may have noticed that I tend to distribute the week's news (about injuries, managerial changes, transfers) throughout my twice-weekly round-ups (and of course, on my Twitter feed), rather than publish copious stories here. I feel, however, like making an exception here.

Santos last night sacked coach Dorival Júnior, the coach who guided them to the Campeonato Paulista and Copa do Brasil titles this year. The dismissal comes in the wake of a brief but telling conflict with one of the team's star players; striker Neymar, recently the subject of a failed transfer bid from Chelsea. The youngster aimed a volley of abuse at Dorival in the wake of the victory over Atlético Goianiense last week, an attack thought to have been provoked by the manager's decision to transfer penalty duties from Neymar to fellow forward Marcel. Dorival subsequently left Neymar out of the draw with Guarani, and was planning to extend the punishment to include tonight's derby clash with Corinthians.

The club's director of football, however, revealed that the punishment laid down by Dorival was not endorsed by the club's hierarchy; "this was not Dorival's decision to take," said Pedro Luis Nunes Conceição, "his behaviour changed and left us astonished." The conflict of opinion lead to Santos officials deciding to end the coach's reign at the Vila Belmiro. São Paulo are reportedly interested in appointing the 48 year-old.

The above statement from Conceição doesn't begin to disguise the idiocy of Santos' decision. Dorival, as well as leading the Peixe to two trophies in the past nine months, has been the catalyst of a wave of positivity surrounding the club, who have achieved success with a thoroughly attacking brand of football. Dorival has also, until recent events, been instrumental in the development of the latest batch of Santos youngsters, including Paulo Henrique Ganso, André, Alan Patrick, and Neymar himself.

Dorival Júnior, I would argue, was entirely in the right regarding recent events. A coach ought to have the final say on discliplinary matters within his squad, and there could be little doubt that Neymar was due a reality check. The youngster has, since signing a new deal with the Peixe a few weeks ago, become the subject of some debate in Brazil. In order to resist Chelsea's overtures, Santos handed Neymar an astronomical contract (by Brazilian standards, at least), making him the best paid player at the club by a considerable distance. Since then, the 18 year-old has frequently displayed petulance on the field, although he is admittedly provoked by his opponents' bully tactics. Off the field, despite pleas by his father to the contrary, Neymar's ego (which, in truth, was never insignificant) is reported to have swelled to dangerous levels.

The blame for the fiasco, however, should not be laid solely at the feet of the young striker. The media attention on Neymar has been intense ever since he burst onto the scene a couple of years ago, and can only have inflated the player's sense of self-importance. Atlético Goianiense coach René Simões last week claimed that the country was "creating a monster," and there is a great deal of truth to this; one could argue that Neymar is turning into precisely the kind of character that the Brazilian media craves and nurtures. Santos' decision, in this context, is not only cruel in the short term to Dorival, but may well prove counter-productive in the development of one of Brazil's best prospects. In ripping apart a successful and popular managerial regime just to ensure Neymar plays in the next few games, Santos have demonstrated themselves to be willing to bend at the youngster's every whim. Who wouldn't develop an ego in such a situation? The sacking of Dorival Júnior stands as a sad indictment of the short-sightedness and short-termism of Brazilian football today.

(A version of this article also appears on IBWM.)


  1. I think it's a lot more than the media though. Some people are just like this. You have the wrong type of people surrounding you. You play a position that typically is full of arrogant a-holes. Many players have come from nothing and have been just as hyped -- Messi, both Ronaldos, Pato. And in basketball -- Durant, Lebron, Dwight Howard. It's just that something happened with Neymar -- long long ago -- this type of personality is something that you just get when you're 7-8 yrs old. The media definitely played a roll, but some people keep their feet on the ground. And frankly, it is unforgivable. I have a hard time liking him now, even on the national team. With some players and their tantrums, I can understand -- like Balotelli, who I feel can legitimately have this badboy attitude. But man... I'm honestly still in shock.

    But maybe it shouldn't be so shocking. It's the same story as always. The star is always bigger than the coach. Even though the coach may have been brilliant. A tragedy indeed and I wish Dorival the best.

  2. Victor, thanks for your comment.

    I agree, it's not JUST the media that's created this problem. Like you say, it's one factor that's contributed to the Neymar we see today.

    Such a shame Santos did this, it gives entirely the wrong message to the player...he needs some discipline and humility before it's too late (if it isn't already).